全球阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停指南质量评价

高怡青, 彭裕, 许华俊, 易红良, 关建, 殷善开

Quality assessment of global obstructive sleep apnea guidelines

GAO Yiqing, PENG Yu, XU Huajun, YI Hongliang, GUAN Jian, YIN Shankai

表2 OSA指南AGREE Ⅱ评分

Tab 2 AGREE Ⅱ scores of OSA guidelines

Guideline Domain Total score/% Recommended level Scope and purpose/% Stakeholder involvement/% Rigor of development/% Clarity of presentation/% Applicability/% Editorial independence/% Mean score (x±s) 79.68±20.38 60.71±22.87 56.07±25.89 75.63±15.61 53.57±15.52 68.52±23.25 63.60±16.45 ‒ AASM2006[10] 61.11 25.00 47.92 77.78 33.33 55.00 49.36 C AASM2007[11] 91.67 63.89 56.25 66.67 39.58 73.33 63.14 A AASM2008[12] 100.00 44.44 64.58 72.22 37.50 80.00 66.03 A AASM2009[13] 61.11 41.67 54.17 66.67 66.67 80.00 61.86 A CSOHNS 2009[29] 33.33 0 10.42 63.89 33.33 20.00 23.40 D CTS2011[41] 100.00 44.44 48.96 66.67 64.58 75.00 63.78 A CMA-CTS2012[30] 44.44 11.11 6.25 66.67 54.17 30.00 30.13 D ACP2013[14] 100.00 44.44 60.42 97.22 39.58 90.00 69.87 A ACP2014[15] 100.00 50.00 64.58 97.22 64.58 90.00 75.64 A ASA2014[16] 66.67 58.33 80.21 72.22 14.58 53.33 59.94 B INOSA2015[39] 44.44 50.00 38.54 72.22 54.17 80.00 54.81 B AASM-AADSM2015[17] 100.00 75.00 89.58 94.44 47.92 100.00 85.26 A CMA2015[31] 55.56 41.67 7.29 63.89 43.75 30.00 33.33 C DG-HNO-KHC2016[37] 50.00 38.89 65.63 72.22 37.50 80.00 59.94 B SASM2016[18] 100.00 61.11 75.00 97.22 62.50 100.00 81.73 A AASM2017[19] 100.00 58.33 75.00 86.11 70.83 76.67 76.92 A ASMBS017[20] 94.44 69.44 75.00 100.00 54.17 66.67 74.68 A AASM-2017[21] 66.67 66.67 15.63 38.89 54.17 60.00 44.55 B SASM2018[22] 100.00 55.56 75.00 72.22 43.75 90.00 73.40 A CMDA2018[32] 75.00 66.67 41.67 72.22 31.25 35.00 49.04 B ATS2018[23] 100.00 97.22 81.25 94.44 68.75 60.00 80.77 A CMA-2018[33] 58.33 55.56 9.38 66.67 52.08 55.00 42.31 C AASM2019[24] 72.22 83.33 67.71 88.89 68.75 60.00 71.15 A VA-DoD2020[25] 77.78 77.78 65.63 72.22 72.92 66.67 70.51 A NICE2021[43] 100.00 58.33 31.25 100.00 62.50 43.33 57.37 C RRSDI2021[40] 88.89 63.89 16.67 63.89 64.58 50.00 49.68 A JRS2021[42] 100.00 100.00 86.46 75.00 68.75 100.00 88.14 A AASM2021[26] 63.89 66.67 25.00 58.33 50.00 75.00 51.60 B AASM-2021[27] 69.44 100.00 79.17 58.33 64.58 88.33 77.56 A ERS2021[44] 100.00 100.00 85.42 83.33 87.50 100.00 91.67 A GSDSM2022[38] 66.67 75.00 72.92 38.89 70.83 80.00 69.55 A SFORL2022[34] 75.00 58.33 75.00 83.33 39.58 85.00 70.51 A USPSTF2022[28] 88.89 83.33 75.00 80.56 54.17 100.00 79.81 A SPLF2010[35] 100.00 66.67 57.29 72.22 37.50 30.00 56.73 B SPLF2014[36] 83.33 72.22 82.29 94.44 64.58 40.00 71.79 A