全球阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停指南质量评价

高怡青, 彭裕, 许华俊, 易红良, 关建, 殷善开

Quality assessment of global obstructive sleep apnea guidelines

GAO Yiqing, PENG Yu, XU Huajun, YI Hongliang, GUAN Jian, YIN Shankai

表4 OSA指南质量亚组分析

Tab 4 Subgroup analysis of quality assessment of OSA guidelines

Evaluation MD (95%CI) American Region vs European Region P value American Region vs Asian Region P value European Region vs Asian Region P value AGREE Ⅱ Scope and Purpose 0.04 (-0.12‒0.19) 0.637 0.23 (0.07‒0.39) 0.005 0.20 (-0.05‒0.44) 0.104 Stakeholder involvement -0.04 (-0.21‒0.14) 0.660 0.15 (-0.05‒0.35) 0.142 0.18 (-0.11‒0.48) 0.203 Rigour of development -0.03 (-0.20‒0.13) 0.688 0.37 (0.13‒0.61) 0.000 0.40 (0.13‒0.67) 0.007 Clarity of presentation 0.00 (-0.16‒0.16) 0.986 0.10 (0.02‒0.18) 0.021 0.10 (-0.09‒0.28) 0.252 Applicability -0.03 (-0.18‒0.11) 0.632 0.03 (-0.09‒0.16) 0.591 0.07 (-0.12‒0.25) 0.435 Editorial independence 0.12 (-0.14‒0.37) 0.319 0.27 (0.10‒0.44) 0.003 0.15 (-0.15‒0.46) 0.295 Total Score 0.01 (-0.10‒0.11) 0.898 0.23 (0.10‒0.35) 0.010 0.22 (0.03‒0.41) 0.026 RIGHT Basic information 0.21 (-0.02‒0.45) 0.068 0.12 (0.02‒0.22) 0.015 -0.09 (-0.33‒0.14) 0.395 Background 0.08 (-0.11‒0.27) 0.356 0.13 (-0.12‒0.39) 0.245 0.06 (-0.24‒0.35) 0.686 Evidence 0.03 (-0.17‒0.24) 0.735 0.47 (0.17‒0.77) 0.006 0.44 (0.12‒0.75) 0.011 Recommendations 0.12 (-0.17‒0.41) 0.361 0.40 (0.23‒0.57) 0.000 0.28 (-0.05‒0.61) 0.087 Review and quality assurance -0.32 (-0.72‒0.08) 0.113 0.00 (-0.37‒0.37) 1.000 0.32 (-0.23‒0.88) 0.234 Funding and declaration and management of interests 0.18 (-0.07‒0.42) 0.159 0.33 (-0.04‒0.71) 0.077 0.16 (-0.31‒0.62) 0.480 Other information 0.06 (-0.24‒0.37) 0.669 0.47 (0.22‒0.73) 0.001 0.41 (0.04‒0.78) 0.032 Total reporting rate 0.09 (-0.13‒0.31) 0.373 0.28 (0.09‒0.47) 0.009 0.19 (-0.07‒0.45) 0.142