收稿日期: 2023-07-14
录用日期: 2023-12-21
网络出版日期: 2024-02-28
基金资助
科技创新2030—“脑科学与类脑研究”重大项目(2021ZD0201900);上海市科学技术委员会科技创新行动计划(18DZ2260200);上海申康医院发展中心促进市级医院临床技能与临床创新三年行动计划(SHDC2020CR2044B)
Quality assessment of global obstructive sleep apnea guidelines
Received date: 2023-07-14
Accepted date: 2023-12-21
Online published: 2024-02-28
Supported by
STI2030?Major Projects from National Key R&D Program of China(2021ZD0201900);Technology Innovation Action Plan of Shanghai Municipal Commission of Science and Technology(18DZ2260200);Three?Year Action Plan of Promoting Clinical Skills and Clinical Innovation of Municipal Hospitals of Shanghai Hospital Development Center(SHDC2020CR2044B)
目的·对全球范围内已发表的阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停(obstructive sleep apnea,OSA)临床实践指南进行质量评价。方法·检索PubMed、Embase、中国知网、万方数据知识服务平台、中国生物医学文献数据库、梅斯医学、The Cochrane Library、医脉通、美国预防服务工作组网站、英国国家卫生与临床优化研究所网站、新西兰指南工作组网站、苏格兰校际指南网络、国际指南协作网等中的OSA相关指南,检索时间限定为建库至2022年12月。由2名研究人员独立筛选文献和提取信息,采用指南研究和评估工具Ⅱ(Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation Ⅱ,AGREE Ⅱ)和国际实践指南报告标准(Reporting Items for Practice Guidelines in Healthcare,RIGHT)对纳入的指南进行质量评价,并按不同指南发布地区进行亚组分析;评价者间一致性采用组内相关系数(intra-class correlation coefficient,ICC)进行检验。对所有纳入指南进行全文阅读,汇总其提出的临床问题。结果·共纳入35篇OSA相关指南。评价者ICC为0.975,显示评价者间一致性较好。AGREE Ⅱ的评价结果显示:纳入指南的平均整体质量分值为(63.60±16.45)%,最低为23.40%,最高为91.67%;6个领域中严谨性[(56.07±25.89)%]和应用性[(53.57±15.52)%]得分较低。RIGHT的评价结果显示,纳入指南的平均总报告率为(67.84±20.03)%,最低为14.29%,最高为94.29%,其中平均报告率较低的领域为评审和质量保证[(31.40±45.51)%]、资金资助和利益冲突声明与管理[(56.43±33.95)%]和其他方面[(56.19±36.85)%]。亚组分析表明,亚洲地区的指南在AGREE Ⅱ的严谨性及整体的质量得分显著低于美洲和欧洲地区的指南(均P<0.05),在RIGHT的证据和其他方面2个领域的报告率也均显著低于美洲和欧洲地区的指南(P<0.05)。纳入的35部指南主要关注了OSA的筛查诊断、治疗及疾病管理3个方面42个临床问题。结论·目前全球OSA指南质量差异较大,各个地区的指南在严谨性、应用性、评审和质量保证、资金资助和利益冲突声明与管理等方面都有待加强,尤其是亚洲地区的指南。
高怡青 , 彭裕 , 许华俊 , 易红良 , 关建 , 殷善开 . 全球阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停指南质量评价[J]. 上海交通大学学报(医学版), 2024 , 44(2) : 237 -249 . DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1674-8115.2024.02.010
Objective ·To evaluate the quality of clinical practice guidelines of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) published worldwide. Methods ·The guidelines of OSA were retrieved in PubMed, Embase, China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Wanfang Data, SinoMed, MedSci, The Cochrane Library, and the websites such as Medlive, U. S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF), National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), New Zealand Guidelines Group (NZGG), Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN), and Guidelines International Network (GIN) from establishment to December 2022. Two reviewers screened the literature and extracted the main information independently, using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation Ⅱ (AGREE Ⅱ) and Reporting Items for Practice Guidelines in Healthcare (RIGHT) to evaluate the quality of the included OSA guidelines. Subgroup analysis was performed according to the publication regions of guidelines. The inter-evaluator consistency test was also performed and the results were expressed as the intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC). All the included guidelines were read entirely and the clinical questions they raised were summarized. Results ·A total of 35 OSA guidelines were included. The ICC value of 0.975 showed a good inter-evaluator agreement. The results of AGREE Ⅱ showed that the average score of all guidelines was (63.60±16.45)%, with a minimum of 23.40% and a maximum of 91.67%. In the six domains, the scores of "Rigor of development" [(56.07±25.89)%] and "Applicability" [(53.57±15.52)%] were relative low. The average reporting rate of RIGHT of all the included guidelines was (67.84±20.03)%, with a minimum of 14.29% and a maximum of 94.29%, and the three domains with the lowest reporting rates were "Review and quality assurance" [(31.40±45.51)%], "Funding and conflict of interest declaration and management" [(56.43±33.95)%] and "Other aspects" [(56.19±36.85)%]. Subgroup analysis showed that guidelines in Asian had a lower score in "Rigor of development" and a lower overall score of AGREE Ⅱ than the guidelines in America and Europe (both P<0.05), and the reporting rates in the domains of "Evidence" and "Other information" of RIGHT of the Asian guidelines were also lower than those in the guidelines in America and Europe (P<0.05). These guidelines focused on 42 clinical questions which were classified to 3 aspects, i.e. screening and diagnosis, treatment and long-term management of OSA. Conclusion ·The quality of current global OSA guidelines varies a lot, and they need to be strengthened in terms of rigor of development, applicability, review and quality assurance, funding and conflict of interest declaration and management, especially those in Asia.
1 | PATEL S R. Obstructive sleep apnea[J]. Ann Intern Med, 2019, 171(11): Itc81-Itc96. |
2 | YOUNG T, PALTA M, DEMPSEY J, et al. The occurrence of sleep-disordered breathing among middle-aged adults[J]. N Engl J Med, 1993, 328(17): 1230-1235. |
3 | HEINZER R, VAT S, MARQUES-VIDAL P, et al. Prevalence of sleep-disordered breathing in the general population: the HypnoLaus study[J]. Lancet Respir Med, 2015, 3(4): 310-318. |
4 | BENJAFIELD A V, AYAS N T, EASTWOOD P R, et al. Estimation of the global prevalence and burden of obstructive sleep apnoea: a literature-based analysis[J]. Lancet Respir Med, 2019, 7(8): 687-698. |
5 | BROUWERS M C, KERKVLIET K, SPITHOFF K, et al. The AGREE Reporting Checklist: a tool to improve reporting of clinical practice guidelines[J]. BMJ, 2016, 352: i1152. |
6 | CHEN Y L, YANG K H, MARU?IC A, et al. A reporting tool for practice guidelines in health care: the RIGHT statement[J]. Ann Intern Med, 2017, 166(2): 128-132. |
7 | 李江, 杨珂璐, 蔡依彤, 等. 全球乳腺癌筛查指南质量评价[J]. 中华流行病学杂志, 2021, 42(2): 219-226. |
7 | LI J, YANG K L, CAI Y T, et al. Quality assessment of global breast cancer screening guidelines[J]. Chinese Journal of Epidemiology, 2021, 42(2): 219-226. |
8 | 郭兰伟, 李江, 陈亚敏, 等. 全球上消化道癌筛查指南的质量评价[J]. 中华流行病学杂志, 2021, 42(7): 1318-1324. |
8 | GUO L W, LI J, CHEN Y M, et al. Quality assessment of guidelines on upper gastrointestinal cancer screening[J]. Chinese Journal of Epidemiology, 2021, 42(7): 1318-1324. |
9 | 李江, 唐威, 李霓, 等. 乳腺癌筛查指南方法学质量和报告质量的系统评价[J]. 中国循证医学杂志, 2018, 18(6): 629-636. |
9 | LI J, TANG W, LI N, et al. Methodological and reporting quality of breast cancer screening guidelines: a systematic review[J]. Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine, 2018, 18(6): 629-636. |
10 | KUSHIDA C A, MORGENTHALER T I, LITTNER M R, et al. Practice parameters for the treatment of snoring and obstructive sleep apnea with oral appliances: an update for 2005[J]. Sleep, 2006, 29(2): 240-243. |
11 | COLLOP N A, ANDERSON W M, BOEHLECKE B, et al. Clinical guidelines for the use of unattended portable monitors in the diagnosis of obstructive sleep apnea in adult patients[J]. J Clin Sleep Med, 2007, 3(7): 737-747. |
12 | MORGENTHALER T I, AURORA R N, BROWN T, et al. Practice parameters for the use of autotitrating continuous positive airway pressure devices for titrating pressures and treating adult patients with obstructive sleep apnea syndrome: an update for 2007. An American Academy of Sleep Medicine report[J]. Sleep, 2008, 31(1): 141-147. |
13 | EPSTEIN L J, KRISTO D, STROLLO P J Jr, et al. Clinical guideline for the evaluation, management and long-term care of obstructive sleep apnea in adults[J]. J Clin Sleep Med, 2009, 5(3): 263-276. |
14 | QASEEM A, HOLTY J E C, OWENS D K, et al. Management of obstructive sleep apnea in adults: a clinical practice guideline from the American College of Physicians[J]. Ann Intern Med, 2013, 159(7): 471-483. |
15 | QASEEM A, DALLAS P, OWENS D K, et al. Diagnosis of obstructive sleep apnea in adults: a clinical practice guideline from the American College of Physicians[J]. Ann Intern Med, 2014, 161(3): 210-220. |
16 | American Society of Anesthesiologists. Practice guidelines for the perioperative management of patients with obstructive sleep apnea: an updated report by the American Society of Anesthesiologists Task Force on Perioperative Management of Patients with Obstructive Sleep Apnea[J]. Anesthesiology, 2014, 120(2): 268-286. |
17 | RAMAR K, DORT L C, KATZ S G, et al. Clinical practice guideline for the treatment of obstructive sleep apnea and snoring with oral appliance therapy: an update for 2015[J]. J Clin Sleep Med, 2015, 11(7): 773-827. |
18 | CHUNG F, MEMTSOUDIS S G, RAMACHANDRAN S K, et al. Society of Anesthesia and Sleep Medicine guidelines on preoperative screening and assessment of adult patients with obstructive sleep apnea[J]. Anesth Analg, 2016, 123(2): 452-473. |
19 | KAPUR V K, AUCKLEY D H, CHOWDHURI S, et al. Clinical practice guideline for diagnostic testing for adult obstructive sleep apnea: an American Academy of Sleep Medicine clinical practice guideline[J]. J Clin Sleep Med, 2017, 13(3): 479-504. |
20 | DE RAAFF C A L, GORTER-STAM M A W, DE VRIES N, et al. Perioperative management of obstructive sleep apnea in bariatric surgery: a consensus guideline[J]. Surg Obes Relat Dis, 2017, 13(7): 1095-1109. |
21 | GURUBHAGAVATULA I, SULLIVAN S, MEOLI A, et al. Management of obstructive sleep apnea in commercial motor vehicle operators: recommendations of the AASM Sleep and Transportation Safety Awareness Task Force[J]. J Clin Sleep Med, 2017, 13(5): 745-758. |
22 | MEMTSOUDIS S G, COZOWICZ C, NAGAPPA M, et al. Society of Anesthesia and Sleep Medicine guideline on intraoperative management of adult patients with obstructive sleep apnea[J]. Anesth Analg, 2018, 127(4): 967-987. |
23 | HUDGEL D W, PATEL S R, AHASIC A M, et al. The role of weight management in the treatment of adult obstructive sleep apnea. An official American Thoracic Society clinical practice guideline[J]. Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 2018, 198(6): e70-e87. |
24 | PATIL S P, AYAPPA I A, CAPLES S M, et al. Treatment of adult obstructive sleep apnea with positive airway pressure: an American Academy of Sleep Medicine clinical practice guideline[J]. J Clin Sleep Med, 2019, 15(2): 335-343. |
25 | MYSLIWIEC V, MARTIN J L, ULMER C S, et al. The management of chronic insomnia disorder and obstructive sleep apnea: synopsis of the 2019 U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs and U.S. Department of Defense clinical practice guidelines[J]. Ann Intern Med, 2020, 172(5): 325-336. |
26 | CAPLES S M, ANDERSON W M, CALERO K, et al. Use of polysomnography and home sleep apnea tests for the longitudinal management of obstructive sleep apnea in adults: an American Academy of Sleep Medicine clinical guidance statement[J]. J Clin Sleep Med, 2021, 17(6): 1287-1293. |
27 | KENT D, STANLEY J, AURORA R N, et al. Referral of adults with obstructive sleep apnea for surgical consultation: an American Academy of Sleep Medicine clinical practice guideline[J]. J Clin Sleep Med, 2021, 17(12): 2499-2505. |
28 | US Preventive Services Task Force. Screening for obstructive sleep apnea in adults: US Preventive Services Task Force recommendation statement[J]. JAMA, 2022, 328(19): 1945-1950. |
29 | 中华耳鼻咽喉头颈外科杂志编辑委员会, 中华医学会耳鼻咽喉头颈外科学分会咽喉学组. 阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停低通气综合征诊断和外科治疗指南[J]. 中华耳鼻咽喉头颈外科杂志, 2009, 44(2): 95-96. |
29 | Editorial Board of Chinese Journal of Otorhinolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Subspecialty Group of Laryngopharyngology, Society of Otorhinolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Chinese Medical Association. Guidelines for the diagnosis and surgical treatment of obstructive sleep apnea-hypopnea syndrome[J]. Chinese Journal of Otorhinolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, 2009, 44(2): 95-96. |
30 | 中华医学会呼吸病学分会睡眠呼吸障碍学组. 阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停低通气综合征诊治指南(2011年修订版)[J]. 中华结核和呼吸杂志, 2012, 35(1): 9-12. |
30 | Sleep Disorder Group of Chinese Thoracic Society. Guidelines for diagnosis and treatment of obstructive sleep apnea hypopnea syndrome (revised in 2011)[J]. Chinese Journal of Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases, 2012, 35(1): 9-12. |
31 | 阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停低通气综合征诊治指南(基层版)写作组. 阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停低通气综合征诊治指南(基层版)[J]. 中华全科医师杂志, 2015, 14(7): 509-515. |
31 | Writing Group of Guidelines for Diagnosis and Treatment of Obstructive Sleep Apnea Hypopnea Syndrome (Primary Version). Guidelines for diagnosis and treatment of obstructive sleep apnea hypopnea syndrome (primary version)[J]. Chinese Journal of General Practitioners, 2015, 14(7): 509-515. |
32 | 中国医师协会睡眠医学专业委员会. 成人阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停多学科诊疗指南[J]. 中华医学杂志, 2018, 98(24): 1902-1914. |
32 | Sleep Medicine Committee of Chinese Medical Doctor Association. Multidisciplinary guidelines for diagnosis and treatment of obstructive sleep apnea in adults[J]. Chinese Medical Journal, 2018, 98(24): 1902-1914. |
33 | 中华医学会, 中华医学会杂志社, 中华医学会全科医学分会, 等. 成人阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停基层诊疗指南(2018年)[J]. 中华全科医师杂志, 2019, 18(1): 21-29. |
33 | Chinese Medical Association, Chinese Medical Journals Publishing House, Chinese Society of General Practice, et al. Guideline for primary care of adult obstructive sleep apnea (2018)[J]. Chinese Journal of General Practitioners, 2019, 18(1): 21-29. |
34 | BASTIER P L, GALLET DE SANTERRE O, BARTIER S, et al. Guidelines of the French Society of ENT (SFORL): drug-induced sleep endoscopy in adult obstructive sleep apnea syndrome[J]. Eur Ann Otorhinolaryngol Head Neck Dis, 2022, 139(4): 216-225. |
35 | Société de Pneumologie de Langue Fran?aise, Société Fran?aise d'Anesthésie Réanimation, Société Fran?aise de Cardiologie, et al. Recommandations pour la Pratique Clinique Syndrome d'apnées hypopnées obstructives du sommeil de l'adulte[J]. Rev Mal Respir, 2010, 27(7): 806-833. |
36 | BETTEGA G, BRETON P, GOUDOT P, et al. Place de l'orthèse d'avancée mandibulaire (OAM) dans le traitement du syndrome d'apnées hypopnées obstructives du sommeil de l'adulte (SAHOS). Juillet 2014[J]. Rev Mal Respir, 2016, 33(6): 526-554. |
37 | VERSE T, DREHER A, HEISER C, et al. ENT-specific therapy of obstructive sleep apnoea in adults: a revised version of the previously published German S2e guideline[J]. Sleep Breath, 2016, 20(4): 1301-1311. |
38 | BERNHARDT O, GIANNAKOPOULOS N N, HEISE M, et al. Mandibular advancement device: prescription in adult dental sleep medicine: guideline of the German Society of Dental Sleep Medicine[J]. Sleep Breath, 2023, 27(1): 389-397. |
39 | SHARMA S K, KATOCH V M, MOHAN A, et al. Consensus and evidence-based Indian initiative on obstructive sleep apnea guidelines 2014 (first edition)[J]. Lung India, 2015, 32(4): 422-434. |
40 | VISWANATHAN V, RAMAKRISHNAN N, SABOO B, et al. RSSDI clinical practice recommendations for screening, diagnosis, and treatment in type 2 diabetes mellitus with obstructive sleep apnea[J]. Int J Diabetes Dev Countr, 2021, 41(1): 4-21. |
41 | FLEETHAM J, AYAS N, BRADLEY D, et al. Canadian Thoracic Society 2011 guideline update: diagnosis and treatment of sleep disordered breathing[J]. Can Respir J, 2011, 18(1): 25-47. |
42 | AKASHIBA T, INOUE Y, UCHIMURA N, et al. Sleep apnea syndrome (SAS) clinical practice guidelines 2020[J]. Respir Investig, 2022, 60(1): 3-32. |
43 | NICE. Obstructive sleep apnoea/hypopnoea syndrome and obesity hypoventilation syndrome in over 16s[M]. London: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), 2021. |
44 | RANDERATH W, VERBRAECKEN J, DE RAAFF C A L, et al. European Respiratory Society guideline on non-CPAP therapies for obstructive sleep apnoea[J]. Eur Respir Rev, 2021, 30(162): 210200. |
45 | World Health Organization. WHO handbook for guideline development[M]. 2nd ed. Vienna: World Health Organization, 2014. |
46 | CHEN Y L, Yang K, MARU?I? A, et al. RIGHT explanation and elaboration: guidance for reporting practice guidelines[EB/OL]. [2022-12-30]. http://www.right-statement.org/right-statement/explanation-and-elaboration. |
/
〈 |
|
〉 |